Australian Payroll Association | News and Resources

When Your Employees Become AI Auditors

Written by Admin | Nov 20, 2026, 3:50:27 AM

By Ross Heron | CEO, Australian Payroll Association
Voice of Confidence | Episode 4 of 7 | Nick Southcombe, Chief Executive Officer, Frontier Software

Ross Heron sits down with Nick Southcombe on forty three years of payroll technology, the real promise of AI and the wave of employee queries heading your way.

You know the moment. Someone taps you on the shoulder, or more likely these days pings you on Teams, and says, "I ran my EBA through ChatGPT and it says I'm underpaid." Your heart sinks. Not because they might be right, but because you know what comes next: an hour of explaining award interpretation to someone whose AI tool had none of the context.

It is a scenario that is already playing out across Australian workplaces, and it came up in one of the most candid conversations I have had in this series. The 2026 APA Payroll Industry Report found that only 13% of payroll teams are currently using AI tools, but as Nick Southcombe pointed out, the other side of the building is not waiting for payroll to catch up.

Nick is Chief Executive Officer at Frontier Software, a company that has been delivering HR and payroll technology globally since 1983. He has led the business since 2007, growing the team from around 207 people in Australia to 380 and supporting more than 1,700 customers across 29 countries. His career in payroll has given him a deep appreciation for the industry's complexity, the evolving demands placed on payroll teams and the dedication of the professionals who keep organisations running.

Discovering the complexity behind payroll

Nick's reflections on his early experiences in payroll offered an interesting perspective on an industry that is often underestimated. Before joining Frontier Software, payroll had largely operated in the background of the organisations he'd worked for. It wasn't until he became more involved in the industry that he began to appreciate just how complex and demanding it really is.

"In probably all the organisations I worked for in the past, I couldn't have told you who the payroll system was," he said. "The complexity of payroll surprised me, and also dealing with payroll professionals more regularly taught me about how passionate they are and how dedicated they are."

That observation, that people outside payroll often have little understanding of what happens behind the scenes, became a recurring theme throughout our conversation.

Nick challenged the perception that payroll is simply a routine administrative function, or what some might describe as a hygiene system.

"It's not," he said. "Businesses are evolving and demands are changing."

His perspective highlights an important reality: payroll is far from static. As organisations evolve, so too do the expectations, responsibilities and complexities facing the professionals and technology providers supporting them.

You don't need to have all the answers

I asked Nick about a leadership belief he had let go of. His answer was something I think every payroll leader needs to hear: "As a leader, you don't need to have all the answers. When you're first promoted to a leadership role, you think you need to have all the answers. You don't need to be omnipresent." What he has become better at, he said, is building good teams, empowering them, making them accountable, and listening.

"Payroll is becoming less and less about the actual processing. You still need a leader there that's going to look at the governance, the risk, the business intelligence. And leading is not just leading your team. You might also need to manage or lead upwards."

That shift, from processor to strategic leader, is exactly what we are seeing in the profession. The skills payroll leaders need are changing, and the soft skills around communication, persuasion and governance are becoming just as important as knowing how to run a pay cycle.

Cut through the AI whitewash

Nick did not hold back on AI hype. "There's a lot of AI whitewashing going on out there," he said. "People are labelling things that are AI which might just otherwise be automation that was there before or business analytics." His view is practical: AI is another tool, and the label matters less than whether it benefits the business.

Where does he see the real return? Workforce management, and specifically, forward looking workforce management. He shared an example from a previous life in the cinema industry, where managers would staff shifts not just based on historical patterns but on what films were coming out, what day of the week it was and whether it was going to rain. "AI has the ability in payroll to go to multiple sources and sort through multiple points of data and come up with plans," he said. That kind of forward looking scheduling, he believes, is under discussed.

He also predicted that in twelve months we will see real AI in payroll products and less whitewashing, and that the industry might skip the Gartner "trough of disillusionment" altogether and move straight to practical application.

The double edged sword no one's talking about

This was the moment in the conversation that stopped me. Nick pointed out that every employee now has access to an AI tool. "They can go to the free version of their favourite tool and say, 'Here's my EBA. Can you check this against my payslip?' And it might come up with an entirely different answer from what you've actually been paid."

"I can see a whole lot of incoming into payroll departments because staff are using AI to drill down. Have I been paid correctly, is my leave balance correct? We've seen it in the Fair Work Commission, which has been swamped with claims lodged using AI."

Most likely the payroll department will be right, Nick said, but the employee's AI tool will not have had the appropriate context. The result? A wave of queries that payroll teams will need to manage, on top of everything else. It is a genuinely important heads up, and one I had not heard anyone else raise so directly.

Catch it on the day, not three years later

Nick was clear that compliance sits with the board and the CEO, but it is a shared responsibility through the organisation. His advice was blunt: "Make sure you've got the right tools, processes and people in place, that you find these things on the day they happen or immediately afterwards, and not three years later, which is what usually happens." With the 2026 APA Payroll Industry Report showing that 65.3% of payroll professionals selected poor or incomplete data as a top operational risk, the case for stronger governance has never been clearer.

On outsourcing, Nick is seeing a growing trend, but he cautioned that organisations often get it wrong at the start. "They see outsourcing as abrogating the risk, and that's not entirely true," he said. The real value, in his view, is freeing your in house payroll professional to focus on governance, control and forward planning while a managed service provider handles the processing.

What this means for you

Payroll professionals: Prepare for a rise in employee queries driven by AI. Start documenting how your award interpretations work so you can respond quickly and confidently when someone arrives with an AI generated pay comparison.

Bookkeepers and accountants: If your clients are using managed payroll services, help them understand it does not remove the risk. It changes where the risk is managed. Governance still sits with the business.

HR professionals: Nick's insight on forward looking workforce management is worth taking to your next planning meeting. AI's biggest payroll return may come from smarter scheduling, not faster processing.

Finance professionals: When evaluating payroll technology investments, ask vendors about their AI strategy. Nick noted this is now a standard RFP question. Check for contract clauses around how your data will be used.

Payroll compliance officers: Nick's "catch it on the day" principle is your mandate. Build governance cadences that surface issues in real time, not in a remediation project years down the track.

Watch the full conversation

This is only half the story. In the full video, Nick also talks about:

  • What ICRIS actually stands for, and the product evolution from CHRIS 3 to CHRIS 21 to the browser based platform it is today.
  • His take on the toughest decisions he has faced as CEO, including walking away from short term revenue to protect a long term strategy.
  • Why he thinks the introduction of the payroll compliance officer, sitting outside the payroll function, is one of the most important changes in the profession.

Watch Episode 4 of Voice of Confidence with Nick Southcombe

This is the fourth of seven Voice of Confidence conversations with leaders shaping Australian payroll. Sign up to Payroll News at austpayroll.com.au/newsletter-sign-up so you don't miss the next one.

Voice of Confidence is the Australian Payroll Association’s leadership series, featuring conversations with the people shaping the future of payroll in Australia.